Home · Editing Services · Blog · Free Quote · Deutsch
Feyre survived, but the price was high: A Court of Mist and Fury, the second book in Sarah J. Maas’s series, is seen by many fans as the moment a fae romance turned into one of the most successful romantasy series of all. The book won the 2016 Goodreads Choice Award for Young Adult Fantasy and Science Fiction. At the same time, hardly any other book in the series is debated as passionately. We analysed press reviews and reader opinions in English and German and summarise what readers love, what they criticize and what writers can learn from it.
Diese Rezension auf Deutsch lesen
At a glance
- Author: Sarah J. Maas
- Published: 2016 by Bloomsbury; German edition 2017 by dtv
- Series: A Court of Thorns and Roses, book 2
- Genre: Romantasy, new adult
- Length: around 640 pages in the original edition
- Award: Goodreads Choice Award 2016, Young Adult Fantasy and Science Fiction
- LovelyBooks (Germany): 4.7 out of 5 stars (around 2,700 ratings, as of November 2026)
What is it about?
Feyre has survived the trials Under the Mountain and is now High Fae. But she returns to the Spring Court changed: what she did to save Tamlin and his people haunts her. At the same time, she has to honour the bargain she made with Rhysand, the feared High Lord of the Night Court. The more time she spends there, the more she learns about the politics of Prythian and about a threat greater than anything she has known.
What readers love about A Court of Mist and Fury
- Feyre’s growth: Many reviews praise that Feyre does not simply move on but struggles with the consequences of what she went through. VoiceMag calls the portrayal of her trauma one of the best written the reviewer has read.
- Rhysand and the Night Court: For many, the relationship between Feyre and Rhys is the heart of the book. Vampire Book Club calls it the best part.
- New characters and a bigger world: With the Night Court, the world opens up considerably. Reviews praise the world-building and the new side characters.
- Not a weak middle book: VoiceMag highlights that the book builds on everything set up in book one and does not feel like a transition.
- Loyal fans: On LovelyBooks, the rating is higher than for the first book. One reader writes that this is the book that made her fall for the series for good.
What readers criticize about A Court of Mist and Fury
- Tamlin’s development: How a central character from book one changes divides readers. Some find the shift understandable, others think it goes too far. Vampire Book Club therefore calls it a love-it-or-hate-it book.
- Explicit content: The series was originally marketed as young adult, but this book contains clearly explicit scenes. Several reviews therefore place it in new adult or adult fiction. Wikipedia reports that the book is among those frequently challenged in US school libraries.
- Writing style: A Literary Escape criticizes repeated adjectives and phrases. Critical voices on LovelyBooks also name the style as a weakness.
- Length: At around 640 pages, the book is considerably longer than the first, which some readers find too long.
Who is A Court of Mist and Fury for?
If the first book made you curious and you are looking for big emotions, a heroine who grows and a richer fantasy world, you will find it here. Note the age recommendation: the book contains explicit scenes, violence and trauma. If you mainly loved the relationship with Tamlin in book one, be prepared for a different direction.
What writers can learn from A Court of Mist and Fury
Take consequences seriously
Feyre does not jump straight into the next adventure. Her trauma shapes the opening of the book. Readers appreciate it when events have tangible consequences.
Bold changes of direction need setup
The debate about Tamlin shows that when a character changes dramatically, hints should be planted beforehand. Otherwise some readers feel cheated.
Be clear about your audience
The dispute over the young adult label shows how important the right positioning is. If you write explicit content, make it clear in the blurb, the category and the content notes.
Conclusion
For many readers, A Court of Mist and Fury made the series what it is today. Feyre’s development, the Night Court and her relationship with Rhys thrill readers, while Tamlin’s shift and the explicit content divide them. For writers, the book is a strong example of how a second instalment can redirect a series.
Sources
For this overview we analysed the following reviews and articles:
- Wikipedia: A Court of Thorns and Roses (series)
- VoiceMag
- Vampire Book Club
- A Literary Escape
- Plugged In
- LovelyBooks: A Court of Mist and Fury
Writing romantasy yourself?
In an edit we check whether your character development is set up, whether your story arc holds and whether your book fits its audience. Try our sample edit: 20 pages for €99.
Keep reading
Legal notice and privacy policy are available in German: Impressum · Datenschutzerklärung