Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarros: What Readers Love and Criticize

Home · Editing Services · Blog · Free Quote · Deutsch

Dragons, a deadly war college and a love interest who wants the heroine dead at first: Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarros shaped the romantasy genre in 2023 like hardly any other book. We analysed reviews and articles online and summarise what readers love, what critics dislike and what you can take away for your own writing.

Diese Rezension auf Deutsch lesen

What is it about?

Violet Sorrengail was trained to be a scribe. But her mother, a general, forces her into Basgiath War College, where dragon riders are trained. The training is deadly, and of all people the powerful wingleader Xaden Riorson has reasons to want Violet out of the way.

What readers love about Fourth Wing

• The pace: Reviews praise how hard the book is to put down. The plot keeps moving.
• Familiar tropes done well: Paste Magazine points out that familiar elements are told so well that they feel fresh.
• The dragons: Many readers love the dragons with their own personalities and the banter between dragons and riders.
• Violet as a heroine: She is not the strongest physically and wins through brains and willpower, which makes her relatable for many.
• The tension between Violet and Xaden: The slow build of their relationship is seen as one of the book’s great strengths.

What readers criticize

• Thin worldbuilding: School Library Journal notes that the world stays thin and that history explanations slow the pace.
• Predictability: Many twists arrive as expected. Readers compare the plot with other well-known fantasy series.
• Modern language: Swearing and slang feel out of place in a fantasy world to some readers.
• Dialogue and exposition: Some readers find the dialogue repetitive and the inner monologue too explanatory.
• Violet’s illness: How the book handles Violet’s chronic illness is judged very differently.

Content notes

Fourth Wing contains explicit scenes, a lot of violence, death and executions, and deals with a chronic illness. School Library Journal recommends it for older readers.

Success and adaptation

According to Wikipedia, Fourth Wing reached number 1 on the New York Times bestseller list and has been translated into around 30 languages. It also won the 2023 Goodreads Choice Award in Romantasy. Amazon is developing a series. Many see the book as one reason the term romantasy is so widespread today.

What writers can learn from it

• Pace beats originality: Familiar tropes work when the execution sweeps readers along.
• Worldbuilding belongs in the plot: Long explanations slow things down, even in a bestseller. Show the world through scenes.
• The relationship needs friction: The enmity between Violet and Xaden carries the whole book. More in How to Write Enemies to Lovers That Readers Believe.

Conclusion

Fourth Wing is a page-turner with dragons, danger and a romance full of tension. Readers looking for a fast, emotional read will be happy. Readers who expect complex worldbuilding and surprising twists are more likely to be disappointed.

Sources

For this overview we analysed the following reviews and articles:

• Wikipedia: Fourth Wing
• Paste Magazine: Fourth Wing Review
• School Library Journal: Fourth Wing
• Goodreads: Fourth Wing

Ratings as of November 2026.

Legal notice and privacy policy are available in German: Impressum · Datenschutzerklärung