Home · Editing Services · Blog · Free Quote · Deutsch
With Verity, Colleen Hoover showed that she can do dark: a psychological thriller with romance elements, a hidden manuscript and an ending readers still argue about. We analysed reviews online and summarise what readers love and what they criticize. No spoilers.
Diese Rezension auf Deutsch lesen
At a glance
- Author: Colleen Hoover
- Published: 2018, self-published, relaunched by Grand Central Publishing in 2021
- Genre: Psychological thriller with romance elements
- Series: Standalone
- Adaptation: In the works, starring Anne Hathaway and Dakota Johnson
- Goodreads: 4.27 out of 5 from more than 4.3 million ratings
What is it about?
Struggling author Lowen Ashleigh gets the chance to finish a bestselling series. The real author, Verity Crawford, can no longer write after an accident. In the Crawfords‘ house, Lowen goes through Verity’s notes and finds an unpublished manuscript that no one was supposed to read. At the same time she feels drawn to Verity’s husband Jeremy.
What readers love about Verity
- Pull: Many readers finished the book in one sitting.
- Eerie atmosphere: The house and the manuscript create an oppressive mood.
- Two narrative layers: Switching between Lowen’s experience and the manuscript builds suspense.
- Something different: Readers appreciate that Hoover writes much darker here than in her love stories.
What readers criticize
- Familiar patterns: Thriller fans find the plot unoriginal and the late twist predictable.
- Similar voices: According to one review, the two narrative perspectives sound too alike.
- An unlikable heroine: Many readers do not warm to Lowen.
- The romance does not quite fit: Some find the love scenes in a thriller unnecessary.
- The ending: For some it is brilliant, for others contrived and unsatisfying.
- Shock effects: According to critics, some topics seem designed mainly to shock.
Content notes
According to reviews, the book contains child abuse, the death of children, graphic violence, infidelity and explicit scenes. It is much more disturbing than Hoover’s love stories.
Success
According to Wikipedia, Verity was relaunched in 2021 after a surge in popularity and won awards including the LovelyBooks Leserpreis 2020 and a British Book Award in 2023. A film adaptation has been announced.
What writers can learn from it
- Voices must be distinguishable. If you use several perspectives, you need clearly different narrative voices.
- Mixing genres takes planning. Romance in a thriller has to support the suspense, not interrupt it.
- A polarising ending must be deliberate. Readers love to debate, but only when they feel it was intentional.
Conclusion
Verity is a fast, disturbing psychological thriller that holds readers to the last page and gets them talking afterwards. Readers who like dark suspense and can handle distressing content will be well entertained. Readers expecting a classic romance are in the wrong place.
Sources
For this overview we analysed the following reviews and articles:
- Wikipedia: Verity
- Goodreads: Verity
- Bookreporter: Verity
- Six Mile Post: Verity
- Eagle Nation Online: Verity
Ratings as of November 2026.
Writing a thriller with romance?
In an edit we check whether your narrative voices are distinct, whether your romance supports the suspense and whether your ending feels intentional. Try our sample edit: 20 pages for €99.
Keep reading
Legal notice and privacy policy are available in German: Impressum · Datenschutzerklärung