Home · Editing Services · Blog · Free Quote · Deutsch
You open the file from your editor and see red markings, comments in the margin and questions about scenes you thought were finished. For many writers, this moment is a small shock. Yet editor feedback is one of the most valuable resources you have as a self-publisher. Here you will learn how to handle comments, how to decide what to accept and how to get the most out of an edit for your book.
Diesen Artikel auf Deutsch lesen
Why editorial feedback often feels bad
A manuscript is personal. Months, sometimes years of work went into it. Criticism of the text therefore quickly feels like criticism of you. That is completely normal. What matters is remembering that your editor is not judging you but helping your text get better. Lots of comments do not mean your book is bad; they mean someone read it very closely.
How to handle feedback
Read first, react later
Read the feedback once from start to finish without replying or changing anything. Then leave it for a day or two. With some distance, you will see more clearly which comments help you.
Start with the big picture
A good edit distinguishes between big issues such as plot, characters and pacing, and small issues such as wording. Deal with the big points first, because they can change entire scenes. Polishing sentences only pays off after that. The difference between editing stages is explained in Developmental Editing vs. Copyediting vs. Proofreading: Which Do You Need?.
Ask why
Behind every comment is a problem the editor noticed while reading. Even if you do not like the specific suggestion, the problem behind it is often real. Ask yourself: what got in the way of the reading experience here?
You have the final say
It is your book. You do not have to accept every change. A good editor makes suggestions and explains them; the decision is yours. But if you reject a suggestion, it should be a conscious choice, not a reflex.
Look for patterns
If similar comments run through the whole manuscript, for example about point of view or filler words, that is a valuable hint for your writing as a whole. Such patterns will also help with future books. Find tips on a common style issue in Filler Words.
What if you disagree?
Say so. A good edit is a dialogue. Explain what you wanted to achieve with a passage and ask how your editor sees the problem. Often you will find a third solution together that is better than both the original passage and the first suggestion.
How to prepare for an edit
- Revise yourself first: The cleaner your manuscript, the more your editor can focus on the important questions.
- Write down your questions: Your editor should know what you are unsure about, for example whether a twist works or whether the middle holds.
- Clarify expectations: What kind of edit do you need, and in what form will you receive feedback?
- Plan time: Revising after an edit often takes several weeks.
Learn how to prepare your manuscript in How to Prepare Your Manuscript for an Editor: Checklist.
Common mistakes when handling feedback
- Rejecting everything at once: If you treat every comment as an attack, you waste the value of the edit.
- Accepting everything blindly: If you accept every change without thinking, you lose your own voice.
- Only fixing small things: Commas are corrected, but the big comment about the plot is ignored.
- Publishing too soon: The book is uploaded straight after the edit without a proofread.
Frequently asked questions about editor feedback
Is a lot of feedback a bad sign?
No. Lots of comments mainly show that the work was thorough. Even very good manuscripts receive many comments.
How many rounds of revision are normal?
It varies. Often an edit is followed by your own revision and then a proofread. With major structural changes, a second round can make sense.
How do I find out whether an editor suits me?
A sample edit shows you how someone works and how their feedback is phrased. Find out more in Sample Edit: Why You Should Test Your Editor First.
Conclusion
Editor feedback is not a verdict but an invitation to make your book better. Read with distance, start with the big issues, ask why and make conscious decisions. Then lots of red markings turn into a book you can be proud of.
Looking for feedback that moves you forward?
With Textamia you get clear, explained comments rather than bare corrections, so you learn for this book and every one after it. Try our sample edit: 20 pages for €99.
Keep reading
Legal notice and privacy policy are available in German: Impressum · Datenschutzerklärung