Home · Editing Services · Blog · Free Quote · Deutsch
A ruthless literary agent from New York, a brooding editor and a small town where the two meet again on a summer holiday: Book Lovers by Emily Henry won the 2022 Goodreads Choice Award for Best Romance and is considered by many to be her strongest book. We analysed press reviews and reader opinions in English and German and summarise what readers love, what they criticize and what writers can learn from it.
Diese Rezension auf Deutsch lesen
At a glance
- Author: Emily Henry
- Published: 2022 by Berkley; German edition 2023 by Knaur as “Book Lovers: Die Liebe steckt zwischen den Zeilen”
- Genre: Romantic comedy, contemporary romance
- Tropes: Enemies to lovers, small town romance
- Award: Goodreads Choice Award 2022, Best Romance
- Adaptation: film rights sold to Tango Entertainment in 2023
- LovelyBooks (Germany): 4.2 out of 5 stars (around 490 ratings, as of November 2026)
What is it about?
Nora Stephens is a literary agent in New York: ambitious, controlled and definitely not the heroine of a small town romance. Her younger sister Libby talks her into spending a summer in Sunshine Falls, North Carolina. There Nora keeps running into Charlie Lastra, an editor she has already clashed with in New York. Charlie grew up in the town and is helping out at his family’s bookshop. When the two end up working on a manuscript by one of Nora’s authors, their rivalry turns into something more. At the same time, Nora senses that Libby is keeping something from her.
What readers love about Book Lovers
- The sisters: The most praised element. Kirkus says the relationship between Nora and Libby is what really brings the tears, and the Marie Claire book club agreed that the sisters are the heart of the book.
- Sharp banter: The verbal sparring between Nora and Charlie is highlighted in almost every review, including AP and Bookreporter.
- A cliché turned around: Usually the career woman from the big city is the rival who loses in the end. Book Lovers makes her the heroine. NPR and AP praise how the book both plays with and subverts this trope.
- The world of books: Agents, editors, manuscripts: anyone who writes or reads a lot will find plenty of references to publishing.
- Depth beneath the romcom: Grief, family and the question of how much you should sacrifice for others give the story more weight than the title suggests.
What readers criticize about Book Lovers
Overall, the response is very positive. Still, a few points come up:
- The romance takes a back seat: Some readers found the love story weaker than the sister storyline. One reader in the Marie Claire book club compared the chemistry unfavourably with People We Meet on Vacation.
- A slow pace: Individual reviews on LovelyBooks found the plot too leisurely.
- Not enough small town adventures: Libby has prepared a list of summer tasks for Nora. One reader would have liked to see more of them.
Who is Book Lovers for?
Book Lovers suits you if you like romcoms with depth, enjoy reading about publishing and appreciate characters who are grown up, ambitious and sometimes uncomfortable. If you mainly want a light story that is romantic from start to finish, be aware that the family storyline takes up a lot of space. The love scenes are steamy, but they are not the focus.
What writers can learn from Book Lovers
Retell a cliché
Emily Henry takes a side character who is only ever the opponent in other novels and tells her side of the story. Ask yourself which character in your genre never gets their turn.
Let the subplot carry the main story
The conflict with Libby strengthens the romance instead of distracting from it: Nora’s fear of losing her sister is the same fear that holds her back in love. Good subplots mirror the theme of the main story.
Dialogue as characterisation
Nora and Charlie reveal who they are in every exchange. When you write dialogue, check whether readers would recognise your characters even without dialogue tags.
Conclusion
Book Lovers is a romcom that takes its characters seriously. The banter and the bookish setting make it fun, but it is the relationship between two sisters that makes it memorable. For writers, it is a strong example of how to give a familiar trope a new point of view.
Sources
For this overview we analysed the following reviews and articles:
- Wikipedia: Book Lovers (with quotes from Kirkus, Publishers Weekly, NPR, AP and Paste)
- Bookreporter
- Marie Claire #ReadWithMC
- Berkeley Fiction Review
- LovelyBooks: Book Lovers
Writing a romcom yourself?
In an edit we check whether your dialogue lands, whether your main plot and subplot work together and whether your characters are more than their trope. Try our sample edit: 20 pages for €99.
Keep reading
Legal notice and privacy policy are available in German: Impressum · Datenschutzerklärung