Bibliotheksregal im Sonnenlicht als Symbol für Funny Story

Home · Editing Services · Blog · Free Quote · Deutsch

A jilted bride, her rival’s ex as a roommate and fake holiday photos: Funny Story by Emily Henry was one of the most successful romance novels of 2024. Netflix has announced an adaptation. We analysed press reviews and reader opinions in English and German and summarise what readers love and what they criticize.

Diese Rezension auf Deutsch lesen

At a glance

  • Author: Emily Henry
  • Published: 2024 by Berkley; German edition 2024 by Knaur under the original title
  • Series: Standalone
  • Genre: Romantic comedy, contemporary romance
  • Tropes: Fake dating, friends to lovers, forced proximity, small town
  • Adaptation: Netflix film in development, written by Emily Henry, no cast yet
  • LovelyBooks (Germany): 4.3 out of 5 from more than 400 ratings

What is it about?

Children’s librarian Daphne moved to the small town of Waning Bay for her fiancé Peter. Then he leaves her for his best friend Petra, and Daphne ends up sharing an apartment with Miles, Petra’s laid-back ex. After a night of tequila, the two decide to fake a summer together in photos for their exes to see.

What readers love about Funny Story

  • Wit and dialogue: Kirkus calls the sharp, funny dialogue Henry’s greatest strength and the book her best yet. German readers praise the mix of humour and real emotion.
  • Miles and the chemistry: Many reviews rave about Miles and the tension between the two. For many he becomes their new book boyfriend.
  • Daphne’s growth: She finds her self-worth on her own, not through the romance, as English and German blogs point out.
  • The town and side characters: Waning Bay, the library colleagues and Miles’s sister Julia are praised even in critical reviews.
  • Depth under a light surface: Family wounds are handled warmly, and the friendship between the leads is the heart of the book for many.

What readers criticize

The criticism is clearly a minority view, but it exists:

  • Too little fake dating: Paste Magazine notes that the deception hardly fools anyone and the expected comic set pieces never come.
  • Manufactured conflict: Dear Author finds the conflict a little manufactured, and several reviews dislike the third-act breakup.
  • Daphne is too passive: Especially with her father and her ex, some readers find her too yielding.
  • A familiar formula: Some fans find the book less distinctive than Henry’s earlier novels.
  • Doubts about Miles: He is hard to read at first. A German blog dislikes his frequent cannabis use.

Content notes

According to reviews, the book deals with childhood abuse and neglect, a breakup through infidelity, low mood after the breakup, cannabis use and some explicit scenes.

Success

According to Wikipedia, Funny Story debuted at number 1 on the New York Times bestseller list and sold more than 800,000 copies in North America by July 2024. It won the 2024 Goodreads Choice Award in Romance.

What writers can learn from it

  • Dialogue carries a romcom. When the exchanges land, readers forgive a lot.
  • Keep your trope’s promise. If you announce fake dating, play out the deception.
  • The third act needs a real reason. A breakup that only serves the structure annoys readers.

Conclusion

Funny Story is a warm, witty romcom with a heroine who finds herself again and a hero many readers love. Emily Henry fans get exactly what she is known for. Readers expecting chaotic fake dating will find a quieter friends to lovers story instead.

Sources

For this overview we analysed the following reviews and articles:

Ratings as of November 2026.

Writing a romcom yourself?

In an edit we check whether your humour lands, whether your conflict grows out of your characters and whether your third act holds. Try our sample edit: 20 pages for €99.

Get a free quote

Legal notice and privacy policy are available in German: Impressum · Datenschutzerklärung